Contact Us for a Free Consultation Today
Nationwide Reach  Our firm provides fearless advocacy for clients involved in Disability Claims & Lawsuits 

Moore v. Menasha Corp.

Docket: 10-2173

Opinion Date: August 22, 2012

Judge: Clay

Areas of Law: ERISA, Insurance Law, Labor & Employment Law

Plaintiffs are retired unionized employees of defendant and were covered by collective bargaining agreements that addressed healthcare benefits. The parties contest whether the CBAs guaranteed employees and their spouses lifetime healthcare benefits after retirement. After retiring, the employees and spouses continued to receive healthcare insurance from defendant. Between ages 62 to 65, defendant paid 80% of the premium costs. When the retirees turned 65, defendant assumed 100% of premium costs. In 2006, defendant informed plaintiffs that the company was instituting a new healthcare plan that would no longer cover 100% of the premiums. Plaintiffs claimed violations of the Labor Management Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. 185, and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, 29 U.S.C. 1132. The district court ruled in plaintiffs’ favor as to employee coverage, but in favor of defendant as to spouses. The Sixth Circuit reversed in part, in favor of plaintiffs. Although healthcare is a “welfare benefit,” not entitled to the same ERISA protection as pension benefits, employers are free to waive their power to alter welfare benefits. Defendant did so by offering vested healthcare coverage to retired employees and spouses, and by agreeing that CBAs could only be modified with signed, mutual consent of the parties.


Client Testimonials

  • “I am blessed for them and their great work and happy to say and my denial for my LTD was overturned”

    - Ricky B.
  • “The insurance company went from hostile to immediately compliant, and quickly reversed their decision.”

    - Greg M.
  • “They are very knowledgeable of current laws and dealing with the big companies too!”

    - David P.
  • “I came away feeling that they generally cared about me and my situation, and were passionate as legal professionals about winning my appeal.”

    - Richard M.

Why hire Burke Harvey?

  • Fearless Advocacy

    Our legal team is focused on providing strong, courageous legal representation for individuals & small businesses.

  • Experienced Attorneys

    Our attorneys have been practicing together since 1994 & are prepared to leverage that experience on your behalf.

  • Strong Legal Guidance

    We believe in making the law approachable by guiding our clients through every step of the complicated legal process.

  • Individualized Solutions

    We are committed to making personalized attention and client-focused representation our highest priority.

Contact the Firm

Schedule a Free Consultation Today
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.